Detailed information on the subject, Delay in Delivery or Faulty Services: How to Prove It
Understanding the Issue
In India, consumers are legally protected against delays in delivery and faulty services under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019. These protections apply whether the purchase is from a local store, a large e-commerce platform, or a professional service provider.
A delay in delivery occurs when a seller or service provider fails to deliver goods or complete services within the agreed timeframe. Faulty services refer to services that fail to meet promised standards, cause inconvenience, or lead to financial or personal loss.
To hold a supplier accountable, you must establish two things clearly: there was a promise or contract specifying the delivery/service standards and the promise was not fulfilled. The strength of your case depends on the quality of your evidence.
Impact on Consumers
Delays and faulty services can have far-reaching consequences:
- Financial Loss: For instance, a delay in delivering raw materials to a small manufacturer can cause missed deadlines and lost clients.
- Emotional Stress: Faulty home renovation services can leave a family living in unsafe conditions.
- Wasted Time: Delays in delivering essential documents or goods can disrupt personal and professional commitments.
- Loss of Opportunity: A delayed travel service or faulty event arrangement can result in irreversible missed opportunities.
Indian law recognizes these impacts and provides avenues for consumers to seek redressal.
Collecting Evidence
Evidence is the foundation of a successful consumer complaint. Without it, your case may not stand in a Consumer Commission. The more thorough and organised your documentation, the stronger your position.
- Purchase Orders and Contracts: Keep all invoices, purchase orders, and written agreements. These documents prove the terms agreed upon.
- Digital Records: Save emails, WhatsApp chats, or SMS that show the agreed timeline or service quality commitments.
- Photographs and Videos: If the service is faulty, record high-resolution, time-stamped photos or videos immediately.
- Delivery Tracking Proof: For online purchases, keep screenshots of shipment tracking showing delays.
- Third-Party Reports: Independent inspection reports can confirm the defect or deficiency.
- Witness Testimony: If anyone else was present during delivery or service, note their statements.
Real-Life Examples
Understanding through examples can help you frame your own complaint better:
- Example 1: A customer orders a refrigerator online with a delivery promise of 5 days. It arrives after 20 days, causing food spoilage and forcing the customer to incur extra expenses. Evidence included the invoice, delivery promise screenshot, and receipts for temporary food storage.
- Example 2: A homeowner hires a contractor for waterproofing work before the monsoon. The work is completed late and poorly, leading to leaks. Evidence included the service contract, weather forecasts proving urgency, and photos of damage.
Legal Provisions in India
Key provisions under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019 include:
- Section 2(1)(o): Defines “service” and what qualifies as a deficiency.
- Section 2(1)(g): Defines “deficiency” in service, covering delays and poor quality.
- Section 35: Allows complaints to be filed with District, State, or National Consumer Commissions depending on claim value.
The Indian Contract Act, 1872 may also apply where there is a contractual breach. In cases involving online purchases, Information Technology Act, 2000 provisions may be relevant.
Filing a Complaint
You can file your complaint either:
- Offline: By visiting the appropriate Consumer Commission office with your documents.
- Online: Through the E-Daakhil Portal, which accepts digital evidence and reduces the need for physical visits.
Steps:
- Prepare your complaint clearly outlining the facts, deficiency, and relief sought.
- Attach copies of all evidence in chronological order.
- Pay the applicable fee based on the claim amount.
- Submit and await acknowledgment from the Commission.
Strengthening Your Case
To increase the chances of a favourable outcome:
- Send a legal notice before filing a complaint, giving the provider a final chance to rectify the issue.
- Highlight any repeated assurances or missed commitments by the provider.
- Calculate and mention the exact monetary loss, supported by receipts.
- Include any mental agony or hardship, supported by context or medical bills if applicable.
Practical Tips
- Act promptly — delay in initiating action can weaken your claim.
- Keep all original documents safe; submit photocopies to the Commission.
- Be polite and factual in all communications — emotional or aggressive language can harm your case.
- Seek help from a consumer rights NGO or legal aid service if needed.
Conclusion
Proving a delay in delivery or faulty services requires a careful blend of evidence collection, legal knowledge, and procedural diligence. By documenting every interaction, knowing your rights under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, and using the right complaint channels, you can maximise your chances of securing justice.
For more information, refer to the Department of Consumer Affairs, Government of India and E-Daakhil Portal.
%20Act,%201970.jpeg)
