Detailed information on Live-in Relationships & Men’s Legal Position in India
Table of Contents
Introduction
Live-in relationships, once considered taboo in Indian society, are increasingly becoming a reality in urban India. While the law does not explicitly regulate live-in arrangements, the courts have gradually recognized them in specific contexts, particularly when it comes to the rights of women and children. But what about men? What is their legal position when they enter into a live-in relationship? This article breaks down the laws, judgments, rights, duties, and risks that men should be aware of before or during a live-in arrangement.
Back to Top
Meaning of Live-in Relationships in India
A live-in relationship generally refers to a domestic cohabitation arrangement where a man and woman live together without formal marriage. In India, such relationships are neither expressly illegal nor explicitly recognized under one codified statute. Instead, their legality has been shaped by judicial interpretations, mostly from the Supreme Court and various High Courts.
Back to Top
Legal Status of Live-in Relationships
Supreme Court Recognition
The Supreme Court of India has repeatedly held that a live-in relationship falls within the ambit of the "right to life and personal liberty" under Article 21 of the Constitution. For instance, in Indra Sarma v. V.K.V. Sarma (2013), the Court observed that live-in relationships are permissible and must be judged on the facts of each case.
Relevant Indian Laws
While there is no specific legislation governing live-ins, the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 (DV Act) covers relationships “in the nature of marriage.” This means women in live-in relationships may claim maintenance or protection orders. However, the law does not explicitly define men’s rights in such arrangements, leaving gaps that men need to be cautious about.
Back to Top
Rights of Men in Live-in Relationships
Right to Cohabitation
Men, like women, have the fundamental right to cohabit with a consenting partner without interference, as upheld in multiple Supreme Court rulings. Police and authorities cannot harass consenting adults who choose to live together.
Right to Protection from False Claims
Though laws primarily protect women, men have the right to defend themselves if falsely accused of abandonment, cruelty, or domestic violence. Courts have, in certain cases, dismissed maintenance claims if the relationship was casual and not akin to marriage.
Back to Top
Duties and Responsibilities of Men
Duty of Care & Respect
Courts often expect men in live-in relationships to uphold similar duties as husbands in marriage, especially regarding respect and dignity towards the partner.
Responsibility Towards Children
If children are born out of a live-in relationship, men have a moral and legal duty to support them, regardless of marital status. Custody, guardianship, and inheritance issues may arise under personal laws and judicial precedents.
Back to Top
Can Men Be Asked to Pay Maintenance in Live-in?
Domestic Violence Act (DV Act) & Maintenance
Section 2(f) of the DV Act recognizes women in a live-in relationship “in the nature of marriage” as having the right to seek maintenance. Men, therefore, may be directed to provide financial support if the relationship resembles marriage in duration and stability.
Judicial Interpretation
In Chanmuniya v. Virendra Kumar Singh Kushwaha (2011), the Supreme Court emphasized that women in live-in arrangements should not be left destitute. For men, this means potential financial liabilities, even without formal marriage.
Back to Top
Property & Inheritance Issues in Live-in Relationships
Jointly Acquired Property
Any property purchased jointly during the live-in relationship belongs to both parties, based on ownership documents. Men should ensure proper documentation to avoid disputes later.
No Automatic Inheritance Rights
Partners in a live-in do not automatically inherit each other’s property, unlike spouses under succession laws. A man’s property passes to his legal heirs unless he specifically includes his live-in partner in a registered will.
Back to Top
False Allegations & Protection for Men in Live-in
Misuse of Laws
Men in live-ins may face false allegations of rape (under the claim of false promise to marry) or domestic violence. Such cases can be traumatic and must be defended legally.
Legal Defenses Available
Courts have clarified that not every failed live-in amounts to rape. In Pramod Suryabhan Pawar v. State of Maharashtra (2019), the Supreme Court held that consensual relationships cannot be equated with rape unless the promise to marry was false from the beginning.
Back to Top
Rights of Children Born in Live-in Relationships
Legitimacy of Children
The Supreme Court in Tulsa v. Durghatiya (2008) recognized that children born out of live-in relationships are legitimate and entitled to inheritance from their parents.
Inheritance Rights
Children can inherit their father’s property under Section 16 of the Hindu Marriage Act, even if the parents were not formally married, provided the live-in relationship was long-term and recognized as “akin to marriage.”
Back to Top
Important Judgments on Live-in Relationships
Supreme Court Judgments
- Indra Sarma v. V.K.V. Sarma (2013) – Recognition of live-ins under Article 21.
- Chanmuniya v. Virendra Kumar Singh (2011) – Maintenance rights for women.
- Pramod Pawar v. State of Maharashtra (2019) – False promise to marry not always rape.
High Court Rulings
- Various High Courts have upheld that adults have the right to live together without societal or police interference.
Back to Top
Legal Risks for Men in Live-in Relationships
Criminal Law Risks
Men may face allegations under IPC Sections 376 (rape), 406 (breach of trust), or 498A (if interpreted as marriage-like). These risks demand vigilance.
Civil Law Risks
Claims for maintenance, shared property disputes, and guardianship issues over children can burden men financially and emotionally.
Back to Top
Precautions Men Should Take Before Entering a Live-in
Written Agreements
Although not common, drafting a cohabitation agreement can help clarify financial responsibilities, property rights, and future arrangements.
Maintaining Evidence
Men should keep records of expenses, ownership documents, and communication to defend against false allegations later.
Consulting a Lawyer
Before entering or during a live-in, seeking professional legal advice can protect a man’s interests and help him understand his liabilities.
Back to Top
What Happens if a Live-in Relationship Breaks Down?
Maintenance Claims
Courts may order men to pay maintenance under the DV Act if the woman proves dependency and a marriage-like relationship.
Custody of Children
Child custody is decided in the best interest of the child. Fathers may get visitation or joint custody, depending on circumstances.
Property Division
Property is divided based on ownership proof. Men can safeguard themselves by keeping records of contributions and legal titles.
Back to Top
Conclusion
Live-in relationships offer freedom but come with legal complexities, especially for men. While the law primarily safeguards women and children, men must be aware of their rights, duties, and risks. The safest approach is to stay informed, maintain transparency, and seek legal advice whenever needed. Responsible choices and awareness can protect men from unnecessary disputes or liabilities.
Back to Top
%20Act,%201970.jpeg)
