Understand these points mentioned in these Case Studies: Top 5 Mistakes Consumers Make When Filing Complaints will help you understand what mistakes not to make.
Filing a consumer complaint in India can be a powerful way to protect your rights under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019. However, many complaints fail because consumers make avoidable mistakes. Below are five realistic case-study style scenarios showing what can go wrong, along with advice on how to avoid these pitfalls.
1. Not Providing Complete Documentation
Case Study: A consumer purchased a high-end mobile phone online but received a defective unit. He filed a complaint with the District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission but only attached the invoice. There was no record of email exchanges with the seller, photographs of the defect, or courier receipts. The seller disputed the claim, saying the product was delivered in perfect condition.
Lesson: Incomplete evidence weakens your case. Always include bills, receipts, photographs, written communication, warranty cards, and tracking details. A well-documented complaint leaves little room for dispute.
2. Filing in the Wrong Jurisdiction
Case Study: A customer bought a washing machine from a chain store in Chennai but filed the case in Bengaluru, where she lived. The Commission dismissed the complaint for lack of territorial jurisdiction, as the transaction occurred in Chennai and the seller’s office was there.
Lesson: The Consumer Protection Act specifies that you can file a complaint where the seller’s office is located, where the transaction took place, or where you reside. Filing in the wrong jurisdiction delays justice and wastes time.
3. Missing the Limitation Period
Case Study: A consumer noticed a defect in his newly purchased refrigerator eight months after delivery. He argued with the shop for another two years before deciding to file a complaint. By that time, the two-year limitation period from the date of cause of action had expired.
Lesson: Under Section 69 of the Consumer Protection Act, you generally have two years from the date of cause of action to file your complaint. File promptly, or provide a valid reason for delay along with a condonation request.
4. Making Emotional, Not Legal Arguments
Case Study: A consumer filed a case against a travel agency for a cancelled holiday package. His written complaint focused heavily on how “hurt” and “angry” he felt, but he did not cite any breach of contract, unfair trade practice, or deficiency in service.
Lesson: Consumer forums decide cases based on legal grounds. Focus on the facts, contractual terms, and specific provisions under the Consumer Protection Act. Emotional language without legal basis won’t win your case.
5. Not Following Up After Filing
Case Study: After filing a complaint about a defective air conditioner, a consumer assumed the forum would handle everything automatically. He missed two hearing dates and did not respond to notices, leading to his complaint being dismissed for non-prosecution.
Lesson: Filing is only the first step. Attend all hearings, respond to notices, and track the progress of your case. You can check case status on the Consumer Case Monitoring System.
Conclusion
Winning a consumer complaint is not just about being right — it’s about presenting your case effectively within the legal framework. Avoiding these five mistakes will significantly improve your chances of success in the consumer forum. Stay prepared, stay informed, and always follow legal procedure.
Suggested Reading:
Understanding Your Consumer Rights in India (2025)
The Consumer Protection Act, 2019: A Complete Guide for Consumers
How to Lodge a Complaint on the E-Daakhil Portal
What Counts as Deficiency of Service Under Indian Law?
Tips to Win Your Consumer Case: Evidence, Arguments, and Strategy
Compensation and Relief in Consumer Cases: What You Can Claim
Landmark Supreme Court Judgments on Consumer Rights
For more information, visit the official Department of Consumer Affairs and the Consumer Case Monitoring System.
%20Act,%201970.jpeg)
